Melshell Oysters is highly praised for its top-quality oysters, with several customers claiming they serve the best oysters in Tasmania. The oysters are fresh, plump, and come in various types, including gold. Many customers appreciate the friendly service and the picturesque location. Some mention the availability of parking and activities for kids. The tours offered by the company, which include harvesting process explanations and oyster shucking lessons, are also highlighted as unique and enjoyable experiences.